Ask and you shall receive – make this ooey, gooey, chocolate chip cookie pie ASAP!
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
Ingredients:
1 stick butter, softened
1 cup sugar
2 eggs
1 teaspoon vanilla
1/2 cup flour
1 cup chopped pecans
6 oz. semi-sweet chocolate chips
dash of salt
1 frozen deep dish pie crust
Directions:
1. Pre-heat oven to 325 degrees. Cream butter and sugar until light and fluffy. Add eggs, one at a time and mix well after each egg. Add vanilla and mix.
2. Combine remaining ingredients into mixture and spoon into pie shell. Bake for 60-70 minutes, or until top is golden brown and center is set. Serve warm!
OMG!








Omg, thank you for this, it sounds sooo good! And it actually isn’t as splurgetastic as I would have thought. I wonder if you can make it in a cheesecake round to make it like a crustless pie? We are just not pie crust eaters in this house and would probably end up scooping out the center anyway
oh ma gawd. this looks to die for! super ooey gooey and i imagine seriously addicting
There was a Kentucky Derby pie in my office refrigerator forever. I think it came from a vendor and no one knew what it was!
thank you kristin!!!
i can’t wait to make it!!!
yay! thank you!
Omg!!
Ok i tweeted this but im going to tell you here too: a favorite coffee shop when i was in high school and college had a Kentucky sundae. It was this pie with ice cream and all the toppings… the funny thing was that it came up as KTNKY Sundae on the receipt and gained its nickname as the kinky sundae
this looks heavenly
Oh my gosh, that looks amazing! Cookie dough and pie?? Heaven!
I’ve never heard of Kentucky Derby Pie, but I sure want to taste all about it : ) Thanks for sharing!
This looks absolutely amazing. Definitely going into my “cook this” list.
Wow, that looks amazing! My boyfriend loves chocolate chip anything and his birthday is next week, looks like I will score super awesome girlfriend points making this for his birthday! Thanks for posting the recipe.
OMG indeed!! Thank you!
I think I might have to bake this someday soon – looks too good to resist! Hope you had a good flight )
Wow that looks amazing! My 24th birthday is this weekend…so I might just have to make this for myself… (well i wont eat the WHOLE thing alone) haha
Is it really only a half a cup of flour?
[...] I also plan to make two desserts this weekend for my birthday. (i’m sorta just using my birthday as an excuse to make them). First is Break up bars. I found these because I read Carrots ‘n Cake quite often and Tina linked back to these bars that her friend made. They just look AMAZING to me! I can’t wait to try them. The second dessert I want to make is from Iowa Girl Eats. The recipe can be found here. [...]
Would it be bad if I made this and ate it all by myself?
How cool to see our family favorite on your blog. My father gave that recipe to me when I was in college. Glad it’s making the rounds!
I made this twice this weekend (2 different parties!). SOOOO good! However, we had a problem with the cook time or temperature …. the pie looked great after cooking 60 min at 325, but was cookie soup in the middle! We ended up cooking it for almost 2 hours to get it to set up. (The 2nd time, I was at another oven. We cranked the temp up to 375 and it was still soupy …). Would you mind double-checking the temp and cook time? Something is just not right — BUT, I will say, the final result was WELL worth the wait … BOTH times! =) THANK YOU! Your recipes are DELIGHTFUL!
I just checked the recipe again and it is indeed 325 degrees for 55-60 minutes. The cooking time may need to be adjusted for older ovens or different altitudes!
I’ve also made this twice now and had the same problem the first time. I fixed it yesterday by baking the pie crust first, then adding the cookie dough. It really helped. And it was delicious both times!
[...] Original Recipe: Iowa Girl Eats [...]
I, too, had to cook the pie longer than 60 minutes, but not too long after, maybe 1 hr. 10 minutes. Middle was still gooey, but it set nicely after a bit.
It was DELICIOUS! Thank you!
I made this for my hubby and I yesterday as a Sunday afternoon treat – HOLY COW, SO GOOD! I had to send it with him to work today so I wouldn’t eat the whole thing. It was super easy to make and sure to please
Thanks for the recipe!
I can’t wait to get home from school for the summer to make this, it looks awesome! Have you ever tried it with an oreo cookie crust instead of just a regular one? I was just thinking, if they’re both cookies……
Do you need to defrost the pie shell first? Or put the filling directly into the frozen shell and then into the oven?
I would just follow the directions on the outside of the pie shell!
It wasnt cooked all the way thur.
[...] the day after), but it is best warm. Look at that yummy gooey center. I also found this recipe via Iowa Girl Eats; so thank [...]
[...] boyfriend loves anything that involves chocolate chip cookie batter, so I thought I’d try out this chocolate chip cookie pie recipe as an alternative to standard [...]
I’ve had pie in the over for an hour and 15 minutes and it is still “soupy”. My oven is a newer model and cooks everything else really well. I live in Kansas so no issues with altitude. Any tips on why the middle isn’t cooking?
I’m not sure! Sometimes ovens cook differently (for instance, my oven cooks “hot” so I always decrease cooking time.) Did it end up setting up?